In Brief

Most busi­ness own­ers are very sym­pa­thet­ic to their staff mem­bers’ oblig­a­tions to their fam­i­lies and gen­er­al­ly except that emer­gen­cies arise which may require an employ­ee to leave the work­place. How­ev­er, it can be very frus­trat­ing when this aris­es at a busy time or fre­quent­ly over a short peri­od. In a recent case, an employ­ee who left work to pick up her son from school was dis­ci­plined and demot­ed result­ing in her res­ig­na­tion. The court found this was breach of the employ­er’s oblig­a­tions and award­ed $32,130.78 in compensation.


Background

On 8 Decem­ber 2011 a friend who usu­al­ly picked up the employ­ee’s son could not make it and the employ­ee was unable to organ­ise some­one else to pick up her son. She informed her man­ag­er she need­ed to leave work ear­ly; her man­ag­er lat­er refused per­mis­sion. With­out any­one else to pick up her son the employ­ee left work early.

The next day the employ­ee received a for­mal warn­ing stat­ing she had aban­doned her respon­si­bil­i­ties. Short­ly after the employ­ee was told she would be trans­ferred to anoth­er store fur­ther away from her home in a low­er posi­tion but on the same pay. The employ­ee said it was dif­fi­cult for her to work fur­ther away because she was preg­nant. Nev­er­the­less she was trans­ferred and felt she was forced to resign.

Law

The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) pro­tects employ­ees from adverse action by their employ­er for a pro­tect­ed rea­son. An exam­ple of an adverse action is dis­missal or demo­tion and an exam­ple of a pro­tect­ed rea­son would be fam­i­ly respon­si­bil­i­ties or if some­one has a work­place right.

Decision

The employ­ee’s oblig­a­tion to ensure her son was picked up from school was a fam­i­ly or car­er’s respon­si­bil­i­ty under the Act. The employ­ee also had a work­place right to take paid or unpaid personal/​carer’s leave due to an unex­pect­ed emer­gency – the need to col­lect a pri­ma­ry school child from school. Deny­ing the request for personal/​carer’s leave and issu­ing the employ­ee with a warn­ing for leav­ing work to pick up her son was adverse action.

On this basis the employ­er con­tra­vened the Act and com­pen­sa­tion of $32,130.78 was ordered.

What to take away?
  • Be aware of an employ­ee’s right to access personal/​carer’s leave.
  • When dis­ci­plin­ing or ter­mi­nat­ing staff because they have tak­en exces­sive leave to look after fam­i­ly, it is crit­i­cal that they are not penalised for exer­cis­ing a nor­mal employ­ee right. Even if in a pro­ba­tion period.
  • It’s a tricky area so we rec­om­mend that you seek advice before chang­ing the con­di­tions of employ­ment for employ­ees who have spe­cial char­ac­ter­is­tics or circumstances.

If you would like to repub­lish this arti­cle, it is gen­er­al­ly approved, but pri­or to doing so please con­tact the Mar­ket­ing team at marketing@​swaab.​com.​au. This arti­cle is not legal advice and the views and com­ments are of a gen­er­al nature only. This arti­cle is not to be relied upon in sub­sti­tu­tion for detailed legal advice.

Publications

Dis­missal for Dissent?

The recent unfair dis­missal deci­sion of the Fair Work Com­mis­sion, Shaun Turn­er v Dare­bin City Coun­cil [2025] FWC 1763, in which Deputy…

Con­struc­tion con­tract time­frames and their inter­ac­tion with the NSW Secu­ri­ty of Pay­ment legislation.

Mark Glynn, Con­struc­tion Part­ner at Swaab con­sid­ers the recent deci­sion of Shar­vain Facades Pty Ltd (Admin­is­tra­tors Appoint­ed) v Roberts Co (NSW)…

10 Tips For Stra­ta Reme­di­al Con­struc­tion Contracts

Are you won­der­ing why your stra­ta work to repair or main­tain your stra­ta build­ing is over bud­get, rid­dled with delays…

In the News

Press Release | New Senior Asso­ciate Appoint­ment — Joshua Bernie

With more than 10 years’ expe­ri­ence in stra­ta and con­struc­tion dis­pute res­o­lu­tion across Aus­tralia and the UK, Joshua brings with him…

Press Release | We are pleased to announce five senior pro­mo­tions in key prac­tice areas of the firm effec­tive, 1 July 2025

Con­grat­u­la­tions:Maris­sa Arag­o­na — AssociateRamesh Chamala — AssociateAaron Boz — AssociateWilliam Clement — Senior AssociateKel­lie Van Mun­ster — Spe­cial Counsel “I am per­son­al­ly delight­ed…

Michael Byrnes quot­ed in the arti­cle, “‘Creep­ing’ unfair dis­missal thresh­old will increase to $183k on 1 July”, pub­lished in HR Leader on 27 June 2025

Michael Byrnes quot­ed in the arti­cle, “‘Creep­ing’ unfair dis­missal thresh­old will increase to $183k on 1 July”, pub­lished in HR Leader…

Sign up for our Newsletter

*Mandatory information