In brief — High Court deci­sion sup­ports franchisors

A recent deci­sion of the High Court of Aus­tralia in Mas­ter Edu­ca­tion Ser­vices Pty Lim­it­ed & Ketchell [2008] HCA 38 has pro­vid­ed some good news for those fran­chisors in Aus­tralia who may on occa­sion be guilty of a rel­a­tive­ly minor and inad­ver­tent omis­sion with respect to their dis­clo­sure oblig­a­tions under the Fran­chis­ing Code of Con­duct (the Code).


Unpaid month­ly fees

Jean Ketchell was a fran­chisee of Mas­ter Edu­ca­tion Ser­vices Pty Lim­it­ed (MES). She got into arrears with unpaid month­ly fees payable under her fran­chise agree­ment and as a result was sued by MES. In defend­ing the claim for unpaid fran­chise fees she alleged that MES, the fran­chisor, had not com­plied with its dis­clo­sure oblig­a­tions under clause 11(1) of the Code. 

She assert­ed that she had entered into a fran­chise agree­ment with­out MES first receiv­ing a writ­ten state­ment from her con­firm­ing that she as a fran­chisee had received and read and had a rea­son­able oppor­tu­ni­ty to under­stand the dis­clo­sure doc­u­ment and the Code (in breach of clause 11(1) of the Code). In essence, Ketchell claimed that this con­tra­ven­tion made the entire fran­chise agree­ment ille­gal and there­fore the fran­chisor was not enti­tled to recov­er the fran­chise fees. 

The mat­ter start­ed in the Local Court and worked its way up to the NSW Supreme Court, then to the NSW Court of Appeal which found in favour of Ketchell, and then to the High Court which reversed the NSW Court of Appeal’s decision.

The High Court’s decision

The High Court found that whilst a con­tra­ven­tion of clause 11(1) of the Code may have occurred, that con­tra­ven­tion did not nec­es­sar­i­ly result in the ille­gal­i­ty and there­fore the unen­force­abil­i­ty of the fran­chise agree­ment. It con­sid­ered that the statu­to­ry frame­work and the leg­isla­tive intent behind the rel­e­vant pro­vi­sions in the Trade Prac­tices Act and the Code did not sup­port the con­clu­sion that a fail­ure to com­ply with every require­ment of the Code will auto­mat­i­cal­ly mean that a fran­chise agree­ment is ren­dered ille­gal and unenforceable. 

The High Court observed that there were a num­ber of reme­dies avail­able to fran­chisees where fran­chisors failed to com­ply with their statu­to­ry oblig­a­tions. The High Court referred to the judge­ment in Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v All­phones Retail Pty Ltd (No 2), which stat­ed that: 

“…it would be an unusu­al result if, in that cir­cum­stance, a fran­chisee’s bar­gain was struck down in every case, regard­less of the posi­tion in which it places the fran­chisee. It is not to be assumed in every case that a fran­chisee wish­es to be relieved of their bar­gain. To ren­der void every fran­chise agree­ment entered into where a fran­chisor had not com­plied with the Code would be to give the fran­chisor, the wrong-doer, an oppor­tu­ni­ty to avoid its oblig­a­tions, and at the same time to place the fran­chisee in breach of oblig­a­tions to third parties.”

Impli­ca­tions for franchisors

The deci­sion of the High Court should not in any way be tak­en by fran­chisors as a rea­son for relax­ing their dis­clo­sure require­ments or any oth­er oblig­a­tions under the Code. How­ev­er, it is com­fort­ing to note that in cir­cum­stances where a fran­chisor makes an inad­ver­tent and arguably rel­a­tive­ly minor omis­sion with respect to the require­ments of the Code, its fran­chise agree­ment will not auto­mat­i­cal­ly become unenforceable.

For fur­ther infor­ma­tion, please contact:

If you would like to repub­lish this arti­cle, it is gen­er­al­ly approved, but pri­or to doing so please con­tact the Mar­ket­ing team at marketing@​swaab.​com.​au. This arti­cle is not legal advice and the views and com­ments are of a gen­er­al nature only. This arti­cle is not to be relied upon in sub­sti­tu­tion for detailed legal advice.

Publications

Three mis­takes landown­ers make when their prop­er­ty is com­pul­so­ri­ly acquired

What should I do if my prop­er­ty is being com­pul­so­ri­ly acquired? This arti­cle explains three com­mon mis­takes landown­ers make and how…

Work­place Rela­tion­ships: The Legal Posi­tion (Jensen Huang/​Nvidia Edition)

The recent sto­ry of Jensen Huang, the co-founder and, until recent­ly, CEO of tech­nol­o­gy com­pa­ny Nvidia, has gar­nered enor­mous media…

Pay­ments ​‘On Account’ Ver­sus Agreed Pay­ments in Con­struc­tion Contracts

Kaloriziko Pty Ltd as trustee for Ryde Com­bined Unit Trust v Cal­i­bre Con­struc­tion Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] NSW­CA 259 con­sid­ered…

In the News

Michael Byrnes appeared on the Mer­i­tas Law Firms World­wide Legal Voic­es: EMEA Employ­ment Law pod­cast episode ​“AI and Work­place Dis­putes” pub­lished on 19 Novem­ber 2026

Michael Byrnes appeared on the Mer­i­tas Law Firms World­wide Legal Voic­es: EMEA Employ­ment Law pod­cast episode ​“AI and Work­place Dis­putes” pub­lished on…

Joshua Bernie is fea­tured in the Novem­ber edi­tion of NSW Liv­ing Stra­ta, pub­lished by @Lookupstrata

Joshua Bernie explains who pays for elec­tri­cal sub­main upgrades in NSW stra­ta schemes. The Novem­ber 2026 edi­tion of Liv­ing Stra­ta…

Michael Byrnes appeared on the pod­cast ​‘Impact and Influ­ence’ episode ​‘Employ­ment Law Essen­tials for Real Estate Lead­ers’ pub­lished on 17 Novem­ber 2026

Michael Byrnes appeared on the pod­cast ​‘Impact and Influ­ence’ episode ​‘Employ­ment Law Essen­tials for Real Estate Lead­ers’ pub­lished on 1…

Sign up for our Newsletter

*Mandatory information