After a lot own­er was suc­cess­ful in its claim for dam­ages in an apart­ment build­ing as a result of an own­ers cor­po­ra­tion’s breach of statu­to­ry duty under sec­tion 106(1) of the Stra­ta Schemes Man­age­ment Act 2015, the Tri­bunal applied rule 38 of the Civ­il and Admin­is­tra­tive Rules 2014 (r38) to award costs despite the ulti­mate award being less than $30,000.

In the case of Ober­to Pty Ltd v The Own­ers Stra­ta Plan No 2004 No 2 (Ober­to), the respon­dent tried to argue against the appli­ca­tion of r38 on the ques­tion of costs because they had ​‘pre-paid’ some of the ulti­mate dam­ages award­ed to the appli­cant. The Tri­bunal did not accept this argu­ment. 

Giv­en that the claim made in Ober­to had exceed­ed $30,000, the Tri­bunal relied on cas­es that dealt with sim­i­lar cir­cum­stances being Allen v Tri­Care (Hast­ings) Ltd [2017] NSW­CAT­AP 25 and Own­ers SP 63341 v Mala­chite Hold­ings PL [2018] NSW­CAT­AP to con­firm that r38 is con­cerned with the amount claimed or in dis­pute, and not the val­ue of the rights affected.

The respon­den­t’s attempt to treat monies paid pri­or to the hear­ing as a ​‘sep­a­rate resolved issue’ in an effort to reduce the amount to be con­sid­ered on the ques­tion of costs under r38, that is, try­ing to bring the amount in ques­tion under $30,000, failed.

The Tri­bunal, agree­ing with the posi­tion of the appli­cant, did not believe the pay­ment was sep­a­rate and instead stat­ed that it was made with the intent that the respon­dent had sim­ply accept­ed that aspect of the claim. The pay­ment was not the prod­uct of nego­ti­a­tion, com­pro­mise, or a con­sent out­come regardless. 

The respon­dent had equal­ly sought to rely on two Calder­bank offers it had sent to the appli­cant, both amount­ing to sub­stan­tial­ly less than the amount claimed. The Tri­bunal had equal­ly dis­missed the notion of both Calder­bank offers as it high­light­ed that on nei­ther occa­sion had the Own­ers ade­quate­ly con­sid­ered the cur­rent cost posi­tion of Ober­to to the date of each offer and simul­ta­ne­ous­ly failed to show that non-accep­tance of the offers would be unreasonable. 

Link to the case: https://​www​.caselaw​.nsw​.gov​.au/​d​e​c​i​s​i​o​n​/​1​9​d​4​2​5​f​8​a​e​a​b​f​7​0​a​6​e​8​9f3ba

If you would like to repub­lish this arti­cle, it is gen­er­al­ly approved, but pri­or to doing so please con­tact the Mar­ket­ing team at marketing@​swaab.​com.​au. This arti­cle is not legal advice and the views and com­ments are of a gen­er­al nature only. This arti­cle is not to be relied upon in sub­sti­tu­tion for detailed legal advice.

Publications

Three mis­takes landown­ers make when their prop­er­ty is com­pul­so­ri­ly acquired

What should I do if my prop­er­ty is being com­pul­so­ri­ly acquired? This arti­cle explains three com­mon mis­takes landown­ers make and how…

Work­place Rela­tion­ships: The Legal Posi­tion (Jensen Huang/​Nvidia Edition)

The recent sto­ry of Jensen Huang, the co-founder and, until recent­ly, CEO of tech­nol­o­gy com­pa­ny Nvidia, has gar­nered enor­mous media…

Pay­ments ​‘On Account’ Ver­sus Agreed Pay­ments in Con­struc­tion Contracts

Kaloriziko Pty Ltd as trustee for Ryde Com­bined Unit Trust v Cal­i­bre Con­struc­tion Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] NSW­CA 259 con­sid­ered…

In the News

Michael Byrnes appeared on the Mer­i­tas Law Firms World­wide Legal Voic­es: EMEA Employ­ment Law pod­cast episode ​“AI and Work­place Dis­putes” pub­lished on 19 Novem­ber 2026

Michael Byrnes appeared on the Mer­i­tas Law Firms World­wide Legal Voic­es: EMEA Employ­ment Law pod­cast episode ​“AI and Work­place Dis­putes” pub­lished on…

Joshua Bernie is fea­tured in the Novem­ber edi­tion of NSW Liv­ing Stra­ta, pub­lished by @Lookupstrata

Joshua Bernie explains who pays for elec­tri­cal sub­main upgrades in NSW stra­ta schemes. The Novem­ber 2026 edi­tion of Liv­ing Stra­ta…

Michael Byrnes appeared on the pod­cast ​‘Impact and Influ­ence’ episode ​‘Employ­ment Law Essen­tials for Real Estate Lead­ers’ pub­lished on 17 Novem­ber 2026

Michael Byrnes appeared on the pod­cast ​‘Impact and Influ­ence’ episode ​‘Employ­ment Law Essen­tials for Real Estate Lead­ers’ pub­lished on 1…

Sign up for our Newsletter

*Mandatory information