In fam­i­ly law dis­putes it is a com­mon mis­con­cep­tion that an inher­i­tance or oth­er large sum received after sep­a­ra­tion will be exclud­ed from the prop­er­ty pool to be divid­ed between the par­ties. This issue was dealt with in the recent case of Calvin & McTi­er [2017] FAM­CAFC 125.

The Full Court of the Fam­i­ly Court in West­ern Aus­tralia heard an Appeal by a hus­band who argued that an inher­i­tance received 4 years after sep­a­ra­tion should not be includ­ed in the prop­er­ty to be divid­ed between him and his ex-wife. 

The par­ties were mar­ried for 8 years and were divorced in 2011.They had one child who was 5 years old at the time of separation.

In 2014 the hus­band received an inher­i­tance from his father’s estate.

The wife com­menced pro­ceed­ings more than 3 years after sep­a­ra­tion and was grant­ed the Court’s leave under Sec­tion 44 (3) of the Fam­i­ly Law Act to pur­sue a prop­er­ty set­tle­ment claim.

The tri­al Judge found that the net val­ue of the assets to be divid­ed between the par­ties was $1,340,319 of which, in per­cent­age terms, the remain­ing inher­i­tance of $430,686 account­ed for approx­i­mate­ly 32% of the asset pool. The hus­band tried unsuc­cess­ful­ly to exclude his inher­i­tance from the asset pool. The tri­al judge assessed con­tri­bu­tions as 75%/25% in the hus­band’s favour and, after mak­ing a 10% adjust­ment to the wife for future needs, divid­ed the prop­er­ty 65%/35% in favour of the husband

The hus­band appealed the decision.

The cen­tral issue on appeal was whether the tri­al Judge erred by includ­ing the hus­band’s post sep­a­ra­tion inher­i­tance with­in the par­ties’ prop­er­ty pool avail­able for divi­sion. The hus­band argued that his inher­i­tance should not be includ­ed in the pool because of the degree of ​“con­nec­tion” or more to the point, the lack of con­nec­tion, between the inher­i­tance and the par­ties’ mat­ri­mo­ni­al rela­tion­ship. The hus­band was unsuc­cess­ful in tak­ing that posi­tion and his appeal was dismissed. 

The Full Court con­clud­ed that the Court retained a dis­cre­tion as to how to approach the treat­ment of prop­er­ty acquired after separation.

The Full Court have approved this deci­sion in two oth­er cas­es, Hol­land & Hol­land [2017] Fam­CAFC 166 and Wid­mann & Wid­mann [2017] Fam­CAFC 602.

Inter­est­ing­ly in the NSW case of Hol­land the inher­i­tance was not includ­ed in the asset pool.

It is impor­tant you obtain legal advice about your par­tic­u­lar cir­cum­stances before you make any deci­sions about divid­ing your prop­er­ty as a there is no one way the Court will deal with post sep­a­ra­tion assets.

If you would like to repub­lish this arti­cle, it is gen­er­al­ly approved, but pri­or to doing so please con­tact the Mar­ket­ing team at marketing@​swaab.​com.​au. This arti­cle is not legal advice and the views and com­ments are of a gen­er­al nature only. This arti­cle is not to be relied upon in sub­sti­tu­tion for detailed legal advice.

Publications

Per­son­al Lia­bil­i­ty for Build­ing Defects: The scope of sec­tion 37 of the Design and Build­ing Prac­ti­tion­ers Act 2020 (NSW)

NSW Supreme Court con­firms direc­tors and project man­agers can be per­son­al­ly liable under sec­tion 37 of the Design and Build­ing…

Pineap­ple on the Piz­za: Rea­son­able Direc­tion to Com­mit a Culi­nary Cul­tur­al Crime

The recent Fair Work Com­mis­sion (FWC) deci­sion in Mr Davide Tam­bu­rel­la v The Trustee For La Cos­ta Hos­pi­tal­i­ty Unit Trust [2026] FWC 4264…

‘Tis the Sea­son to Avoid Fol­ly: Work­place Christ­mas Par­ties (2026 Edition)

It’s that time of year. The ​‘Sil­ly Sea­son’. For many organ­i­sa­tions, the offi­cial employ­er Christ­mas par­ty is imminent.The start­ing point for…

In the News

Michael Byrnes is quot­ed in the arti­cle, ​“What will Australia’s land­mark AI enforcer mean for employ­ers?”, pub­lished in HR Leader on 13 Novem­ber 2026

Michael Byrnes is quot­ed in the arti­cle, ​“What will Australia’s land­mark AI enforcer mean for employ­ers?”, pub­lished in HR Leader…

Michael Byrnes is quot­ed in the arti­cle, ​“Sky­dance staff buy­out offer at Ten poten­tial­ly rais­es legal red flags”, pub­lished in Mum­brel­la on 6 Novem­ber 2026

Could Sky­dance’s staff buy­out offer at Ten cre­ate legal risks or employ­ment law issues?Michael Byrnes is quot­ed in the arti­cle, ​“Sky­dance…

Michael Byrnes appeared on McK­night Tonight with Robert McK­night on 4 Novem­ber 2026 to dis­cuss the lat­est devel­op­ments in the Jack­ie ​‘O’ Hen­der­son v ARN case (from 3:42 to 18:30)

Analy­sis of the lat­est Fed­er­al Court devel­op­ments in Jack­ie O’s case against ARN, includ­ing priv­i­lege rul­ings, the board memo and…

Sign up for our Newsletter

*Mandatory information